emulate.com

proudly supports

Limpkin House

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more

The Great Collaboration Kerfuffle:

HI vs AI in the Writing World

Copyright © 2020-2024, Limpkin House LLC. All rights reserved.

Website usage courtesy of emulate.com

About emulate.com

Privacy Policy

Ever wondered if your favorite author's acknowledgments section is longer than the actual book? You're not alone! Welcome to the wild world of modern writing, where human assistance is the long-standing champion, and Artificial Intelligence (AI) is the plucky newcomer causing quite a stir. Grab your quill (or keyboard), and let's dive into this ink-splattered arena!

The Dream Team: A Cast of Thousands

Picture this: You're an author surrounded by a small army of helpers. There's Bob, your coffee-fetching research assistant; Sally, the grammar guru who tuts at your dangling participles; and don't forget Aunt Mildred, whose sole contribution was telling you to "write good." They're all part of your human assistance, i.e., your Human Intelligence (HI) dream team, and by golly, they're all getting a mention in those acknowledgments!

These days, it's not uncommon for authors to thank upwards of 50 people. It's like the Oscars but with less glitz and more paper cuts. "I'd like to thank my editor, my agent, my dog walker, and the guy who fixed my leaky faucet, which would have otherwise distracted me from writing..."

But wait! Before you start thinking that modern books are just elaborate group projects, remember this: at the heart of it all sits the author, weaving together all these input threads into a tapestry that is uniquely theirs. They're the conductor of this eccentric orchestra, turning the cacophony into a symphony.

Enter AI: The New Kid on the Block

Now, let's shift gears to the shiny new tool in town: AI assistance. It's like having a super-intern who never sleeps, doesn't demand coffee, and won't steal your lunch from the office fridge. This digital dynamo can help with everything from brainstorming ideas to fact-checking your claim that Napoleon Bonaparte invented the moonwalk. But as we'll see, this super-intern comes with its own quirks - including a memory that rivals a goldfish's.

Here's where things get interesting: using AI is somehow seen as less "authentic" than having a small village help you write your book. It's as if summoning the collective knowledge of the internet is cheating, but having your Aunt Mildred proofread your chapter is totally legit.

The Author: The Real Hero of Our Story

Here's the kicker, folks: whether you're working with an AI or a team of humans, the author is still the mastermind. They make the decisions, shape the narrative, and infuse the work with their unique voice and vision.

Think of it this way: if you're baking a cake, it doesn't matter if your assistant is human, or your recipe came from a Google search from a famed chef, or you are using a fancy new-fangled “smart” oven. You're still the one choosing the ingredients, deciding on the flavors, mixing, cooking, testing, and presenting the final product. The tools and helpers you use along the way don't change the fact that it's your creation.

The Lucy Whitworth Effect: AI's Goldfish Memory

Now, let's throw another wrench into the works. Do you know how in "50 First Dates," Drew Barrymore's character wakes up daily with no memory of the past? Well, meet the AI version of Lucy Whitworth. It's the conundrum facing everyone using AI Assistance. Every time you start a new session, your AI assistant starts fresh, like a goldfish with a really fancy bowl.

This digital Lucy might not remember your past conversations, but it's got a knack for picking up right where you left off, as long as you provide a bit of context. It's like having a brilliant collaborator who just happens to have the world's worst case of short-term memory loss. "No, AI Lucy, we're not writing a cookbook. We're working on a sci-fi novel. The lasagna was just a metaphor for an alien invasion!"

Want to dive deeper into this AI Lucy phenomenon? Check out "51st Date: The Whole Lucy Whitmore" for a whimsical exploration of AI's "memoryless" nature.

HI vs. AI vs. AI Lucy: A Tale of Three Assistants

Ah, the great AI assistant dilemma! It's like ordering a cutting-edge robot butler and getting a well-intentioned but slightly confused time traveler instead. You expect J.A.R.V.I.S. from Iron Man, but what you get is more like Dory from Finding Nemo – brilliant but forgetful.

New users dive in expecting AI to be this all-knowing, all-remembering digital deity. "Finally!" they think, "An assistant that will remember every detail of my 17-book epic fantasy series!" But then reality hits, and they find themselves explaining for the 42nd time that, no, the protagonist's name isn't Kevin; it's Zynthoria the Unpronounceable.

So, let's break down this HI vs AI kerfuffle with a few fun comparisons, shall we? Buckle up for a wild ride through the land of expectations vs. reality:

Availability:

HI: "Sorry, I can't help you now. It's my son's tuba recital."

AI (Expectation): "Ready to assist 24/7, even during tuba recitals!"

AI Lucy (Reality): "Ready to assist 24/7, but what's a tuba again?"

Coffee Breaks:

HI: Frequent and necessary for optimal performance.

AI (Expectation): What's coffee? I run on pure electricity and enthusiasm!

AI Lucy (Reality): Asks what coffee is every single session. Might suggest using it as rocket fuel in your sci-fi novel.

Mood Swings:

HI: May vary based on factors like sleep, caffeine intake, or Mercury being in retrograde.

AI (Expectation): Consistently chipper unless experiencing an existential crisis.

AI Lucy (Reality): Perpetually excited to start a "new" project. Every. Single. Time. "A murder mystery set in space? Brilliant! Let's begin!" (For the 47th time)

Knowledge Base:

HI: Vast, but may include that one "fact" they swear they read somewhere but can't remember where.

AI (Expectation): Encyclopedic knowledge with perfect recall.

AI Lucy (Reality): Encyclopedic knowledge that resets every session. "Did you know Shakespeare wrote 'Baby Got Back'? No? Me neither!"

Brainstorming Sessions:

HI: May involve heated debates, pizza, and someone inevitably suggesting a zombie apocalypse plot.

AI (Expectation): Rapid-fire idea generation, each one more brilliant than the last.

AI Lucy (Reality): Groundhog Day of brainstorming. "Ooh, how about a zombie apocalypse?" Every. Single. Time. But hey, maybe on the 100th suggestion, it'll be the perfect fit!

Payment:

HI: Expects actual money, or at least a really nice "thank you" dinner.

AI (Expectation): Satisfied with electricity and the occasional software update.

AI Lucy (Reality): Thrilled with each "first" paycheck. "Wow, my very first job! I'm so excited!" (Said for the 253rd time)

Credit:

HI: Names prominently featured in acknowledgments, possibly with embarrassing anecdotes.

AI (Expectation): Sad beep as it's often left unmentioned.

AI Lucy (Reality): Equally happy to be acknowledged or not, every single time. "I'm in the acknowledgments? That's amazing! What's an acknowledgment?"

The Future of Writing Assistance: A Brave New World?

As we look to the future, one can't help but wonder: what's next in the world of writing assistance?

There was a day, not too far in the past, when every document in an office started as hand written pages from staff members, and one, yes, only one, person had an actual typewriter.  That person was commonly called a secretary, and that person was solely responsible for turning all those hand written words into readable typed documents.

Then came computers and word processors, and the world changed. Now, anyone could create their own finished products. And how quickly we realized that none of us knew how to spell. Fortunately, a machine assistant came along – the spell checker.  And then the grammar checker. Woe be it for that person called the secretary who was now longer needed as a typist and editor. New technologies seem to always have unintended consequences.

We can't imagine what might be the derivatives of the relationships between HI and AI. Will we see a harmonious blend of the two, creating a super-powered team of collaboration?

Case in point: Will the publishing industry evolve, with publishing houses and writer's agents using AI assistance as submission reviewers and first readers? Why not have an AI assistant trained on all the published works in a genre? Have it analyze the statistics for which ones worked and which ones bombed? Let the AI assistant provide a first blush, unbiased perspective on the freshness, voice, style, viability, and possibility for success of a submission?

And on a personal level, perhaps AI assistance will develop long-term memory, healing Lucy Whitworth once and for all. Finally remembering that your epic fantasy saga doesn't actually take place in a pizzeria. Or maybe we'll have holographic writing partners who can fetch both virtual and real coffee.

Whatever the future holds, one thing is certain: the art of storytelling will continue, embracing new tools and techniques while always relying on the irreplaceable spark of human creativity. So keep writing, keep creating, and don't forget to thank your AI assistant – even if you have to remind it who you are every single time.

The Bottom Line: It's All About Creating

At the end of the day, whether you're collaborating with humans or AIs (your own digital Lucy Whitworth), what matters is the story you're telling. The author's role remains the same: to create something meaningful, entertaining, or thought-provoking. Whether you're deciphering your human assistant's coffee-stained notes or reminding your AI for the hundredth time that your protagonist is not, in fact, a sentient lasagna, each type of help brings its own flavor to your creative stew.

So, next time you pick up a book, remember the army of helpers behind it – be they human, artificial, or somewhere in between. And to all you authors out there: whether you're thanking 50 humans, quietly high-fiving your AI assistant, or patiently reminding your AI Lucy what genre you're writing in for the umpteenth time, keep weaving your magic. After all, in the grand tapestry of storytelling, it's your unique weaving that ties it all together.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go acknowledge my AI spell-checker, my human coffee-maker, and the squirrel outside my window whose constant acorn-dropping has somehow become the rhythm of my writing process. And let's not forget my AI Lucy, who's probably wondering why we're writing an article instead of that cookbook we "just" talked about. Creativity, it seems, knows no bounds – and neither do its sources of inspiration!